How Harry Styles is Breaking Gender Norms
December 7, 2020
From the moment a child is born, he or she is unknowingly confined by their assigned gender. Women have been expected to hold “emotional” and “nurturing” characteristics, and in contrast, men should be perceived as “strong” and “dominant.” As society has progressed and people have become more confident in their own identities, men and women have broken these stereotypes that have constricted them for centuries.
Musicians have notably broken various gender norms, from Lady Gaga performing as her male alter-ego, Jo Calderone, to Prince, who sported platform heels and “flamboyant” outfits while he performed to thousands on stage. The music industry has made significant strides towards dismantling gender stereotypes, and more recently, Harry Styles, a prior member of the popular boy band One Direction and now solo artist, has also questioned the boundaries of gender conformity.
As the first male to cover Vogue solo, Harry Styles already sparked the media’s interest with his December-edition appearance in the acclaimed magazine; however, many were less focused on this accomplishment, but rather Styles’ fashion choice. Despite his past of experimenting with an androgynous style, the English singer’s wearing of a dress caused a great commotion throughout the media.
Specifically, political activist Candace Owens, took to her social media to express her opinions on Harry Styles’ Vogue cover. Known for her strong, and often controversial opinions, Owens tweeted, “There is no society that can live without strong men” following with, “Bring back manly men.”
Even as more guys sport skirts and polished nails in working towards destigmatizing feminine men, those with conservative mindsets seem to still detest gender progression. While it is harmless and empowering for many men to break toxic masculinity — “a set of attitudes and ways of behaving stereotypically associated with or expected of men, regarded as having a negative impact on men and on society as a whole” — many still believe men must be masculine (Oxford Languages).
Although some strongly disagree with femininity in men, others have found it freeing. Styles explained that “There’s so much fun to be had in playing with clothes” (Vogue). With a similar philosophy, Sammy Baloch (12) noted that she believes that “clothes are genderless” and “anyone can wear a dress.”
Harry Styles has remained a role model for individuals around the world for over ten years, and his bravery to deny the prominent gender stereotypes that still linger in the 21st century has not gone unnoticed. Brandon Vega (12), a Harry Styles supporter, finds his style to be “empowering for boys like [him] who have grown up with social pressures” to appear unemotional and macho.
While stereotypes have significantly weakened as more and more individuals continue to overcome gender norms, traditionalists still oppose a world without gender roles. Men in dresses remain a taboo topic that many can not wrap their heads around.
Candace Owens beliefs’ on Harry Styles’ femininity are not only controversial but also damaging to young, impressionable minds. Her outright toxicity has severe consequences among the masses, as it only intensifies the social pressures men and women face daily. Not every woman may want to flaunt a shaven haircut and not every man feels exceedingly confident in a gown, but in a society that has formed intense boundaries when it comes to gender expression, people like Harry Styles are instrumental in paving the way for individuals to express themselves freely.
Suhani Bhanvadia • Dec 14, 2020 at 4:17 PM
I was so confused when I heard people were upset about this. Breaking gender norms shouldn’t be offensive to anyone as the whole point is to embrace what people like regardless of their gender. I’m so glad Harry Styles is using his platform to do good.
Katelyn Ruggles • Dec 11, 2020 at 2:36 PM
I love that Harry Styles is able to express himself confidently and be comfortable in his one skin, which is what I think makes man, not the “tough guy” look, and I think this article spread light to that message!
Hayden MacDonald • Dec 10, 2020 at 7:01 PM
Absolutely breathtaking article Riley! Seriously incredible! Wow! I think this topic is so important for people to be truly free from society’s expectations. I have found Harry’s style as inspiration in how I dress, but I have been nervous to wear unconventional clothes in school as well as in public. Amazing job!
Anita Tun • Dec 10, 2020 at 8:37 AM
I think it’s amazing that Harry Styles is breaking gender norms and is empowering to other boys across the world!
danielle huizar • Dec 8, 2020 at 11:54 AM
When I heard about this controversy, I found myself confused about why so many people were so angered about Harry Styles wearing a dress. I like how you included the history of musicians breaking “gender norms,” and the development of masculinity in our modern culture. I definitely agree that Candace Owens and other political commentators’ comments on this is harmful, and hopefully, in the future, society would not care if a man decides to wear a dress. This is an extremely well-written article!
Sarah Lemos • Dec 8, 2020 at 9:21 AM
When I first heard about Harry Styles wearing a dress on the cover of Vogue, I was unsure of why this would cause drama. I am actually really happy for the breaking gender norms. I hope Mr. Styles knows he is definitely advocating for a good cause.